Skip to content 
In this fictional scenario, prosecutors seek a lengthy sentence because of the severity of the offense and Maya’s alleged role.
The defense argues that the sentence is disproportionate given her age.
After considering the arguments, the judge announces the sentence.
Eighty-six years in prison.
The courtroom becomes silent.
Maya looks toward her family.
Her mother begins crying.
The victim’s relatives sit quietly.
The number hangs in the room.
Eighty-six years.
For a teenager, it represents almost an entire lifetime.
The Meaning of a Sentence
A prison sentence serves several purposes.
It can punish a person for wrongdoing.
It can protect society from someone considered dangerous.Violent Crime
It can provide a measure of justice for victims.
And, ideally, it can provide opportunities for rehabilitation.
But when a sentence is extremely long, rehabilitation becomes more complicated.
A person sentenced at 17 could enter prison as a teenager and potentially spend decades behind bars.
During that time, they may change dramatically.
They may mature.
They may earn educational qualifications.
They may participate in counseling.
They may develop remorse.
They may become entirely different from the person who committed the crime.
That raises a difficult question:
Should the justice system leave room for that possibility?
The Science of Adolescent Decision-Making
One reason juvenile sentencing remains controversial is that adolescence is a period of major development.
Teenagers can understand right and wrong.
They can make deliberate choices.
They can also be held accountable for serious wrongdoing.
But their judgment and impulse control continue developing into early adulthood.
Young people can be particularly influenced by peers.